Debate: Conversational AI and young people’s mental health – friend or foe? – more than a ‘good or bad’ story: a self-determination theory approach to conversational AI and adolescent well-being – Psychiatry AI: Real-Time AI Scoping Review

AI Summary

Conversational AI can support adolescents' competence by offering learning assistance, but risks fostering superficial skills without deeper mastery.
It can enhance relatedness through emotional and relational support while potentially displacing human relationships and reducing genuine social connection.
Effects on autonomy vary: AI may increase independence and choice but can also constrain authentic autonomy depending on use, purpose, and context.

AI Summary

This article applies a Self-Determination Theory lens to explore how and under which conditions adolescents' conversational AI usage supports or frustrates their basic psychological needs for competence, relatedness, and autonomy.

Conversational AI may enhance competence through learning assistance, relatedness through emotional and relational support, and autonomy through increased independence.

Overall, the role conversational AI plays in adolescents' development is unlikely to be universally positive or negative for all adolescents, but instead depends on how, why, and in which context these technologies are used, highlighting the need for nuanced research and developmentally sensitive design.

Basic summary

Child Adolesc Ment Health. 2026 Jul 4. doi: 10.1111/camh.70109. Online ahead of print.

ABSTRACT

The rapid adoption of conversational AI among adolescents has sparked growing debate about its implications for development and well-being. This article applies a Self-Determination Theory lens to explore how and under which conditions adolescents’ conversational AI usage supports or frustrates their basic psychological needs for competence, relatedness, and autonomy. Conversational AI may enhance competence through learning assistance, relatedness through emotional and relational support, and autonomy through increased independence. At the same time, it may also promote the risk of superficial competence, displace human relationships, and constrain authentic autonomy. Overall, the role conversational AI plays in adolescents’ development is unlikely to be universally positive or negative for all adolescents, but instead depends on how, why, and in which context these technologies are used, highlighting the need for nuanced research and developmentally sensitive design.

PMID:42400316 | DOI:10.1111/camh.70109

Document this CPD