- UPT correlated with traditional objective performance measures (p < .05), but showed no correlation with subjective EF rating scales (p > .05).
- UPT performance was not associated with mood symptoms (p > .05), indicating relative independence from affective influences compared with other EF measures.
- No evidence that UPT better captures self-direction than traditional tests, yet it offers an unstructured alternative less confounded by mood.
J Clin Exp Neuropsychol. 2026 Oct 31:1-11. doi: 10.1080/13803395.2026.2757683. Online ahead of print.
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Executive functions (EFs) are higher order cognitive skills implicated in various neurodevelopmental and psychiatric disorders, including ADHD. Yet, there is a range of strategies for measuring EFs, with commonly used objective performance-based measures and subjective rating scales often yielding weak associations. This discrepancy may reflect objective measures relying on highly structured test administration procedures and rating scales’ greater ability to capture self-direction, everyday functioning, and emotional aspects of EF. The present study evaluated the concurrent validity of a novel unstructured performance task (UPT) designed to assess self-direction in university students.
METHOD: One hundred twenty-one university students were included in the study. Performance was compared across the UPT and commonly used EF objective measures and rating scales. The relations between each EF measure and mood symptoms were also assessed.
RESULTS: Scores on the UPT were correlated with the performance measures (p < .05), though neither were correlated with the rating scale (p > .05). Unlike performance measure and rating scale scores, the UPT was unaffected by mood symptoms (p > .05).
CONCLUSION: No evidence was found suggesting that the UPT better captures self-direction compared with traditional performance measures. However, the UPT may provide an alternative, unstructured EF measure that is relatively less related to mood symptoms. .
PMID:42966858 | DOI:10.1080/13803395.2026.2757683
Share Evidence Blueprint
Save to Google Notes

Search Google Scholar
⭐ My Revision List

