- Severe depression undermines cognitive autonomy, rendering valid consent for psychiatric assisted dying impossible.
- Expansion of MAiD for mental illness risks structural coercion within an underfunded healthcare system.
- Policy must demand rigorous evidence and prioritise comprehensive care to protect vulnerable patients over expedient assisted death.
Healthc Q. 2026 Jul;29(2):14-16. doi: 10.12927/hcq.2026.27909.
ABSTRACT
This paper critiques an expansion of Medical Assistance in Dying for psychiatric illnesses in Canada, utilizing Orlando Da Silva’s memoir, Thank God I Failed, as a central case study. It argues that severe depression impairs cognitive autonomy, making consent impossible and exposing patients to structural coercion within an underfunded healthcare system. By analyzing the intersection of physical and mental suffering, the text challenges health system utilitarianism and the artificial segregation of pain. Ultimately, it calls for rigorous evidentiary standards in healthcare policy, emphasizing the system’s fundamental obligation to protect vulnerable patients and prioritize comprehensive care over expedited assisted death.
PMID:42669636 | DOI:10.12927/hcq.2026.27909
Share Evidence Blueprint
Save to Google Notes
Search Google Scholar
Save as PDF
⭐ My Revision List
